Bad Beef By Design
Every day lately we seem to get re-taught the lesson that if for some crazy reason you actually wanted to design a system to produce unsafe food, well, you could do worse than to copy the one we've got here in the U.S. Today's reminder is this report: 75,000 pounds of American beef is being recalled because of E. coli contamination, including meat sold by Albertsons and Save-A-Lot stores in Arizona, California, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, North Dakota, Oregon, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming.
What do I mean when I say that the system we've got produces food that makes us sick? Over the years in the U.S. we've developed an approach to food that consists of a public policy of warping the production process and a Reagan-esque "no government is good government" approach to oversight of the food we eat.
Let's start on the policy side, particularly with the federal farm bill that Congress considers every five years. (Actually, Congresses is working on the next version of the farm bill right now. I'll put a link to more on that process at the end of this post.) One thing that our federal farm policy does is to subsidize the production of enormous amounts of one product -- corn. So American farmers produce piles and piles of corn, and the trick then becomes for us to figure out what to do with it. One thing we do is to shove into a variety of shapes and dye it different colors and sell its as cereal for $4 or $5 a box. That takes care of some of it.
But much of what's left goes to feed American cows. Farmers like corn because it can turn a calf into a hulking beast more quickly than other feed. The problem? Cows are evolved to eat grass. Their digestive systems aren't built to process that much corn. And so it makes them sick. Their digestive systems adapt (with the help of a great deal of antibiotics), but in doing so they create an acidic stew in their bellies that is the perfect environment for E. coli to grow in. In the slaughtering process, the bacteria passes from the cow's stomach into the cut beef. Then of course it's onto our dinner plates, and into our stomachs. (Michael Pollan does a tremendous job detailing the link between corn and E. coli in his book The Omnivore's Dilemma.)
Of course, in theory we have a particular federal agency charged with overseeing the food production process and keeping us safe when we eat. But an FDA agent in every barn and slaughterhouse is an invasive, big government approach that's been out of favor in recent years. Today's FDA prefers a more targeted approach; an Associated Press investigation of federal records found that between 2003 and 2006 FDA inspections dropped by 47 percent.
And we've all learned lately that our food worries don't begin and end with American hamburger. I'm sure you remember the many cats and dogs that got sick and died during the recent contaminated pet food situation. Where'd all that bad stuff come from? After some digging, it was discovered to be China, in the form of melamine-contaminated wheat gluten, corn gluten, and rice protein concentrate.
We import an enormous amount of food from abroad into the United States, from China and elsewhere -- about $10 billion more than we export, it seems. But at the same time, we're not inspecting a whole lot of that food. FDA inspections of imports have declined by about 1/3 since 2003. The FDA examines 1.3% of the food that comes into the United States. (All these number come from the same article linked above, here.) That's small, hands-off government, right there.
Beyond this talk of federal legislation and an ideological approach to governing, there's a certain simple truth we need to accept, one that that I think is well captured by this guy, Michael Doyle, the director of the Center for Food Safety at the University of Georgia:
We have a food safety crisis on the horizon.
We made that crisis. We've built a system that produces unsafe food. Now we've got to figure out a way to fix it.
(Here's the link I mentioned above, on the farm bill. Congressman Earl Blumenauer of Oregon is blogging on the bill all week at TPM Cafe.)
- FILED UNDER: Editor Posts
- June 5, 2007









Thank you Nancy
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
XXX
- Email this page
By ginardoJune 5, 2007 - 5:54pmTake the red pill...
Have You Heard of the Meatrix?
Do You Want to Know What IT is?
http://www.themeatrix.com/
and then
http://www.veganoutreach.org/
and where and when possible, by local and organic.
- Email this page
By queerveganJune 5, 2007 - 6:03pmThe Dutch are actually trying to grow meat in a lab.
http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2007/06/eating_meat_wit.html
On some great & glorious day the plain folks will reach their hearts desire at last, & the White House will be adorned by a downright moron. - H.L. Mencken
- Email this page
By Guy FawkesJune 5, 2007 - 6:39pmSounds tasty
Here's the rest of that article from Reuters
- Email this page
By ginardoJune 5, 2007 - 7:19pmprogress but...
...for some reason this makes me feel queezy.
I predict Soylent Green will be the next film to have accurately predicted the future.
- Email this page
By queerveganJune 5, 2007 - 7:39pmvegan
Yea I was being sarcastic. I still have nightmares over that scene in the Matrix when new infants were fed the liquified juices of the dead.
- Email this page
By ginardoJune 5, 2007 - 7:45pmBut...Soylent Green is
But...Soylent Green is PEOPLE!!!!
"And the question in my mind is how many additional American casualties is Saddam worth? And the answer is not very damned many."
—Cheney, at the Discovery Institute in Seattle, Washington, August 1992.
- Email this page
By MichtouJune 5, 2007 - 7:55pmpeople are meat
People are meat too! Just ask a lion or Cheney.
- Email this page
By queerveganJune 6, 2007 - 6:07amGM Beef
Gm beef is great! Isn't it? We have cheaper meat, better looking and with more nutrients. But we're not sure yet that it's ok for us to eat it and consumers have no way of knowing what meat is GM when they go to the supermarket. At least they should add stickers so we can choose what we eat :)
Easy beef recipes
- Email this page
By karen183February 25, 2008 - 6:35amWe're not meant to eat cows
Cows are one of the least efficient makers of protein available. I stopped eating red meat 15 years ago, and now it just smells BAD, like carcasses. Cooking meat smells like burning carcasses. I stopped because I had cancer and my doctor told me to stop, not because I had any pressing desire to become a vegetarian. Now I see what a waste of land and resources growing meat is. Even chickens are a more efficient protein turnover than cattle or pigs are. We could really help the planet by not eating meat or fish.
"And the question in my mind is how many additional American casualties is Saddam worth? And the answer is not very damned many."
—Cheney, at the Discovery Institute in Seattle, Washington, August 1992.
- Email this page
By MichtouJune 5, 2007 - 6:48pmMichtou
Yea I only eat fish (mostly Salmon) or chicken about 2 or 3 times a week, and I'm trying to cut down on that. What we are doing to the oceans is absolutely tragic. 2o years from now, we will remember these days with nostalgia I'm afraid.
- Email this page
By ginardoJune 5, 2007 - 7:34pmMakes me glad I have a peptic ulcer
I had to quit meat and other hard to digest foods as a result about 1 1/2 years ago. My liver was producing too many enzymes to break down what I was eating, which gave me the ulcer.
I have felt better and lost weight as a result. I have nothing but good things to say about the lifestyle now.
When I think of what I used to eat, I get sick to my stomach. Six months ago I tried to eat a chicken sandwich and nearly threw up. Now the only meat I can eat is seafood. I have never been so healthy.
I still couldn't give a crap about animals, though. ;)
The obscure we see eventually. The completely obvious, it seems, takes longer. ~Edward R. Murrow
- Email this page
By MarkBrownJune 5, 2007 - 10:06pmSeafood
Seafood is a good source of the nutrient: Mercury! Not sure what the RDA is on that one but I am sure we are doing our best to fortify our bodies of water with plenty!
- Email this page
By queerveganJune 6, 2007 - 6:23amHas anyone seen the super
Has anyone seen the super cows? Run a search in google or google images for super cow and you'll see genetically engineered cows that look like they were fed steroids, they have huge masses of muscle. I'm a meat eater but cant imagine this being to good for you. I had a bad ulcer got a prescription and filled it with an online pharmacy just because the lady at ride aide is a pain to even talk to and has a major altitude problem.
- Email this page
By mginsMarch 24, 2008 - 12:23pmCoast to Coast AM had a great caller Monday night
The caller said that he has taken to buying solid cuts of chuck beef and grinding his own hamburg at home. He stated that the claim made by markets that their meats are 'fresh ground daily' actually involve prepackaged sacks of course ground meat (which may have had many sources) that the market will then regrind, thoroughly mixing in what ever contaminate it may have contained.
Meat grinders are not very expensive, and think about the lean quality you can make by trimming out the fat, and gristle. The grinders are easily cleaned with hot soapy water.
I'm lucky to still have my grandmother's hand crank grinder which I find easier to use for making Hash than breaking out the big Osterizer.
Plant a garden, or a container garden for apartment dwellers, and grow some things. It's educational for the kids, and you can't beat HOME GROWN flavor.
It's not safe letting Chimpy's friends put food on your family.
"Invest In America Buy A Congressman"--evolvefish
One election at a time......
- Email this page
By pb_trueJune 6, 2007 - 12:14amChina made Toothpaste recall...China has a plan
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/6725595.stm
China acts over poor food safety
China is cracking down on poor food safety amid a string of scares over toothpaste, pet foods, and other goods.
The government published a five-year plan late on Tuesday to increase inspections and tests on exported food.
[...]
"Food safety is not only a problem related to law enforcement, but also related to the people's health and safety, the country's image, and also bilateral and multilateral political relationships," said Li Changjiang, the head of China's main food safety agency.
In the future "illegal activities behind production and sale of fake and shoddy foods and pharmaceuticals will be effectively contained," the five-year plan says.
Mr Li, and his deputy Wei Chuanzhong, called for better safety testing, and for those who ignore safety regulations to be punished.
"Invest In America Buy A Congressman"--evolvefish
One election at a time......
- Email this page
By pb_trueJune 6, 2007 - 9:55amIs 5 a magic communist number
I know I'm being facetious, but it seems to me that almost every plan in communist countries comes in 5-year increments.
.
"And the question in my mind is how many additional American casualties is Saddam worth? And the answer is not very damned many."
—Cheney, at the Discovery Institute in Seattle, Washington, August 1992.
- Email this page
By MichtouJune 6, 2007 - 7:25pmThat's right...we have to go vegan!
We need food that is all soy and tofu based so we can all get our full dose of estrogen and become a nation of crying wimps whenever something goes wrong in our lives.
Now lets get some of that e-coli laced spinach and scallions over here...YUM!
- Email this page
By voltarJune 6, 2007 - 8:55amcrying wimps?
When are you joining up to go to Iraq? Where did Bush and Cheney or anyone else in the Bush Crime Family serve? Seems like you and your masters are the wimps!
- Email this page
By hufflarry2000June 6, 2007 - 11:43amI can't stand beef, but my
I can't stand beef, but my father-in-law raises two steer on his land every year for his kids. Every fall we get a side of beef (wwaaaayyyyy too much for my family of three, especially since I'm the one who cooks it, and not often). However, at least I know how it's raised, what it's fed and who butchers it. Plus, what we don't eat, which is most of it, we donate to the homeless shelter and domestic violence shelter.
- Email this page
By libgirlJune 6, 2007 - 9:47amthis scares me
G.M.foods.....steroids,hormones in out meat,milk.....we are letting these F***KERS do this to us....what could happen? well we will tell you in 20yrs. when our 20yr study of you in done...just say know..then just say NO!!!!!!!!.Is it time to rapture these fake christians yet?
- Email this page
By shlogerJune 6, 2007 - 12:02pm